Lessons from 10 of the worst engineering disasters in us history. One investigative team prepared its failure report in a week. Recent investigations into the disaster have revealed that the st. The st francis dam photo from field of science rather than a natural disaster, this flood was a failing of manmade civil engineering. Francis dam california, 1928 case study asdso lessons. That back story, as well as tales of survivors, neverbeforeseen photographs and unique maps will be the focus of sundays opening reception of the santa. The collapse of the dam prompted the creation of over a dozen separate investigations into the cause of failure. The ensuing flood killed hundreds and swept away thousands of acres of fertile land the st. Francis dam disaster and its historiography by abraham hoffman w hen the st. Francis dam failed just hours after being inspected by mulholland himself, and sent 12. Francis dam disaster, 6 contemporary photo postcards including generators, 1928.
The failure released 36, 180 acrefeet of water down. Francis dam disaster dam failure, california, united states. No one knows the true cost in lives lost, but it is estimated that more than 600 people were drowned, mangled by debris or impaled by trees when the concrete dam failed moments before midnight. Rather than a natural disaster, this flood was a failing of manmade civil engineering. Francis dam disaster, theres an oftenoverlooked back story of the events that led to the building and collapse of the st. Francis dam in 1928 is one of the worst catastrophes of the twentieth century. Frank said that the bodies were found in san diego. In what many consider the worst civil engineering disaster of the 20th century, the resulting flood wave rampaged for more than five hours through the night, destroying thousands of acres of farmland, ripping apart a thousand structures, and cutting short. He was an illiterate and selfeducated man who eventually became the most renowned civil engineer in california, building 19 dams through his career, said rock, who recently hosted a tour. The middle section of the dam was blasted away in 1929 after a teenage boy climbing the attraction fell to his death.
An investigation into the disaster concluded that it had been caused primarily by the unsuitability of the san francisquito rock for supporting a dam and a reservoir. Francis dam disaster by john nichols arcadia publishing. Nearly six hundred people were killed, making the disaster californias second. Francis dam failure march 12, 1928 devastating disasters. The dam is unwittingly built against an ancient paleolithic landslide on its eastern abutment. The dam was prone to the concrete cracking, and mulholland examined the dam on numerous occasions, but assured everyone that this was normal. Examples of wellknown dam failures that caused fatalities are the 1923 collapse of gleno dam in italy 1.
Mulhollands was an original ragstoriches story, said santa clarita valley resident frank rock, who has spent years studying the st. A primary source for this documentary will be my book, floodpath. The blocks in front of the tombstone were later found to have come from the eastern side of the dam, and apparently sheered off the stepped portion of the lower part of the tombstone. The dam s 200foot concrete wall crumpled, sending billions of gallons of raging flood waters down san francisquito canyon, sweeping 54 miles down the santa clara river to the sea, and claiming over 450 lives in the disaster. The ensuing flood killed hundreds and swept away thousands of acres of fertile land. March 12, 1928 date is generally reported as march, 1928. Francis dam leaked, collapsed, and flooded the surrounding areas. Mar 12, 2015 or, sort of like new york citys 1904 general slocum disaster, perhaps there was just too much else going on in the years immediately following the st. Vajont dam because the incident was caused by a landslide of unstable hillside, and the st. However, the dam collapsed on march 12 th, 1928 leading to the worst flooding experienced in californias history. Francis dam collapsed on march 12, 1928, news of the tragedy was reported throughout the nation and in many other countries.
In some of these catastrophic flood events, human error, neglect, or miscalculation contributed to the scale of the disaster. A dam is a barrier across flowing water that obstructs, directs or slows down the flow, often creating a reservoir, lake or impoundments. Initiation of the forgotten casualties project, a mutliyear study under the direction of archaeology professor james snead of california state university, northridge. The blocks in front of the tombstone were later found to have come from the eastern side of the dam, and apparently sheered off the stepped portion of the lower part of. At two minutes to midnight on the 12th march, 1928, the st. The picture above is of the tombstone, the one portion of the st. Flooddamaged properties, san francisquito canyon, 1928 ws2801 cleanup at power house no. Francis dam ruins application of the method of characteristics to the dam break wave problem, journal of hydraulic research, 47 1, pp. Francis failure was due to an unstable hillside of paleolandslide. Although undoubtedly running a weak second in mcmullens initial thoughts, by the time he finished the paper the disaster got top billing.
Francis dam california, 1928 draft document open pdf 4 mb this interactive pdf was developed to supplement the dam incidents and failures lessons learned information sharing llis webpage and contains information regarding the failure of st. It possesses all the usual characters of a california dramathe wealthy industrialists, big city politicians, scandal, and tragedy are all readily apparent. Francis dam stand ready to turn water into electric power. Francis dam disaster site historical landmark description. Reasons for this are probably due to the sudden failure of the relatively. Dec 05, 2016 a dam is a barrier across flowing water that obstructs, directs or slows down the flow, often creating a reservoir, lake or impoundments. A number of errors are made in the construction of the foundation of the dam, except at its center section. In other words when the water reached the ocean at ventura the currents washed the bodies from ventura all the way to san diego. Or, sort of like new york citys 1904 general slocum disaster, perhaps there was just too much else going on in the years immediately following the st. Mar 12, 20 one investigative team prepared its failure report in a week.
Francis dam collapse is one of the defining stories of modern california history. Many of the sleepy residents of the san francisquito canyon mistook the shaking and. It was three minutes before the stroke of midnight on a windy march 12, 1928, when the st. The dam was opened in 1926 after taking two years of construction. Dec 31, 2016 the picture above is of the tombstone, the one portion of the st. Captured here in over 200 images is a photographic record of the devastation caused by the flood, and the heroic efforts of residents and rescue workers. Around midnight on march 12, 1928, just days after its reservoir was full for the first time, the st. Because of this privilege and the decisions that he made william mulholland bears responsibility for the st. Francis dam disaster, march 12, 1928 santa paula times. Francis dam disaster collection of the huntington library.
Francis dam flood dis aster with other contributions will be acknowledged and listed as they arc received death valley scotty was read more. Mar 11, 2001 the second worst disaster in california history began on march 12, 1928, near midnight, in the remote san francisquito canyon area of saugus. Buffalo creek flood because its construction and mode of failure were entirely dissimilar. Image created using arcmap gis software version 10. This collection of articles about the dam includes contributions from catherine mulholland, william mulhollands granddaughter, and dr. The dam, completed in may, 1926, rested on a foundation imbedded 30 in the earth. Francis dam was a curved, concrete, gravity dam in san francisquito canyon, two hundred feet high, with a span of six hundred feet across the mouth of the canyon, and a dike along one side of the canyon. In the photo above, the reservoir lake is still several feet below the lip of the dam.
For example, the failure of the saint francis gravity dam in usa with the height of 63 m was arisen as a result of soft dam foundation and collapse of rock stratum, which caused sliding leading to. Francis dam that survived the collapse of march 12, 1928. Francis dam disaster, castaic bridge wreckage, march 1928. Francis dam santa clarita, california atlas obscura.
Francis dam disaster, catastrophic dam failure in california on march 12, 1928, that was one of the worst civil engineering failures in american history. Dam failure and flood event case history compilation bureau of. The first is, the st francis dam disaster revisited, edited by doyce b. Francis dam disaster, flood victims crossing river, march 1928. By peggy kelly santa paula timesalthough most santa paulans are familiar with the story of the st. Towns affected were castaic, piru, fillmore, santa paula, and saticoy. Overnight on march 12, 1928, the dam failed, washing out its contents 52 miles 84 km to the. Francis dam disaster, photos shot march, 1928 10 views. Minutes before midnight on the evening of march 12, 1928, the st.
The disaster was initially blamed on the failure of the west abutment. Francis dam was built on an ancient landslide, which would have been undetectable to engineers of the 1920s. William mulhollands career ended on march 12, 1928, when his st. The dams 200foot concrete wall crumpled, sending billions of gallons of raging flood waters down san francisquito canyon, sweeping 54 miles down the santa clara river to the sea, and claiming over 450 lives in the disaster. Shortly after construction had begun it was decided to raise the height of the dam 10 feet, which would increase the. Nov 06, 2002 minutes before midnight on the evening of march 12, 1928, the st.
On march 12, 1928, just before midnight, it collapsed and sent over twelve billion gallons of water roaring down the valley of the santa clara river. The saint francis dam collapse and its impact on the construction of the hoover dam was submitted in 2004, but a it wasnt. The y2k bug was the longawaited disaster that didnt happen. Francis dam disaster 30minute television program available online. The mixture of the concrete is also of questionable quality and workmanship. Francis dam failure since i first found out about it. Francis dam had been open two years and its reservoir had filled to capacity for the first time when tragedy struck. Francis dam disaster dam failure, california, united.
Mar 12, 2015 it was three minutes before the stroke of midnight on a windy march 12, 1928, when the st. His reputation became highly regarded due to his success in engineering the. That it is counted as both a natural and engineering disaster speaks to the likely cause of the dam break. Mcmullen had an avid interest in the construction of the hoover dam, the subject of his planned master of science thesis. The st francis dam was a concrete archgravity design taking two years to build, being completed in 1926.
1450 1547 440 1462 790 99 1042 33 1288 498 650 434 1246 1308 1534 1202 1303 352 1432 1632 258 1385 1150 1574 40 389 1406 1490 498 1358 1092 815 524 1058 670 1276 1165 1038